Bye, Bye, Marty

June 22, 2005

I still get a number of hits to my post about the firing of Christian talk show host Marty Minto. I never quite finished it because I got tied up in more important things, so I decided to come back and do just that. For those interested, the original entry can be found in its entirety (misspellings, bad grammar, and all) here.


04/14/05: Marty makes the AP newswire

Marty Minto, winner of the 2004 Pittsburgh Achievement in Radio Award for Best Afternoon Show on a News Talk, Personality or Sports Station, has been fired by Christian radio station WORD-FM (owned by Salem Communications) for “alienating listeners”. In addition to working for three years as host at WORD-FM, Marty is senior pastor of Turning Point Community Church in New Castle. Readers of this blog may have read posts about or inspired by his show. “Marty Minto Show” producer Shaun “Powerball” Pierce announced the news on PowerBlog.

“It is with mixed emotions that I inform all of you that the Marty Minto show is no more. Marty is no longer employed with WORD FM.”

“I have produced the show for 3 years now. I owe Marty a debt of gratitude for the challenges he presented. He caused me to search the scripture and grow stronger in my own personal faith. For that I will always be grateful, despite the fact that we disagreed on many issues. I consider Marty a friend and I wish him the best in his future endeavors.”

“As for the program, I will still be producing the show. The same time, same station. We will have guest hosts for awhile as we develop a brand new and exciting program.”

“PowerBlog will be here for you. As things continue to develop, I will keep you informed. I ask all of you for your prayers and continued support and we embark on new journey together.”

The news was surprising but not a complete shock. Marty upset a lot of listeners with his controversial – and lopsided – discussions about Catholic theology. He also made enemies among his listeners by criticizing The Purpose Driven Life for its shallow and deficient theology (something I actually agreed with him on). I contacted WORD-FM via email on Tuesday to find out if there would be an official press release regarding Marty’s departure. Operations manager Kenny Woods replied in the negative.

“Thanks for your email. Marty is no longer with the station. The search for a replacement show or host is now underway. Please keep us and our future host in your prayers as we begin looking! There is no official press release scheduled at this time.”

“God Bless, and thanks for listening to 101.5 WORD-FM.”

I suspect Mr. Woods and the remainder of the WORD-FM administration may now wish they had made an official statement. AP picked up the story and as of today it has gone national. The fact that The Drudge Report highlighted it certainly contributed to that. The AP article may have been based on one published in the Pittsburgh Tribune Review, which contained lengthier (and more contextually rich) quotes.

“‘I was called into the office after my show Friday and told that I was being let go because I was alienating the listeners,’ said Minto, 39, of New Castle, Lawrence County, who previously did talk-radio shows in Albany, N.Y., Phoenix and Denver. Minto also is senior pastor of the 100-member Turning Point Community Church in New Castle.”

“‘As far as I’m concerned, I was doing what I’ve always done on the radio — look at events around the world from a biblical perspective,’ said Minto. ‘I’ve always been willing to talk about controversial subjects.'”

“Chuck Gratner, general manager of WORD-FM for the past 14 years, said the station does not dispute Minto’s account of events.”

“‘We ended our relationship’ with him because of differences in how he conducted his show, Gratner said.”

“‘WORD-FM needs to function in this city in support of the entire church — that means everybody — and not focus on denominational issues,’ he said.”

Marty has been interviewed by Pittsburgh ABC affiliate WTAE-TV 4 and had the following to say.

“I have never been fired, never been let go. I just don’t understand. I haven’t done anything like a Howard Stern or went against any FCC rule or regulation.”

“I asked listeners if they’re getting too much or not enough of the 24/7 coverage”

“I find it hard to believe I’m alienating people. My lines have been jammed all week. Hundreds of e-mails. I believe I had a right to share. It’s a talk show. It’s controversial because of the topics we talk about. I am appalled that, all of a sudden, my so-called brothers and sisters in the world have now said, ‘You are no longer allowed to say anything; we’re firing you. We’re quenching your speech because you went too far.'”

BTW, he’s thinking of speaking with an attorney. Good luck, Marty. Pennsylvania is a “hire and fire at will” state. Unless he can prove that WORD-FM fired him for illegal reasons (race, age, sex, religion, etc), he’d just be wasting his time and money taking them to court. The station was merely looking out for its best interests. If he was alienating investors and advertisers, the station’s ability to broadcast at all was threatened. It’s better to cut one controversial show loose than to lose the whole station.

Comments 8

  1. Steve N wrote:

    Christianity Today has picked up the story here.

    Posted 16 Apr 2005 at 6:58 am
  2. Rob wrote:

    Christians suing Christians proves that we do not take the gospel seriously. Plenty of non-Christians will have their ideas about Christianity confirmed if such a lawsuit is filed.

    Come to think of it, there’s a lot of us Christians who will have their ideas about fellow Christians confirmed by that lawsuit.

    Posted 15 Apr 2005 at 10:14 pm
  3. Rob wrote:

    Eric,

    At least I’m self-employed. I can’t be fired for blogging what I think. How people react at church might be a different matter, but one I’m prepared to deal with.

    How about you?

    If Marty speaks with an attorney, that will be disappointing. Somehow, Christians suing Christians just looks real bad.

    So tell me, how do we heal the Christian community and the Christians from this hurt?

    Posted 15 Apr 2005 at 3:34 pm
  4. Jerry Nora wrote:

    It’s too bad. I would rather have a big Christian personality (okay, big with regard to Pittsburgh!) who would rally Catholics and Orthodox, rather than have a link on his personal website to “Good News for Catholics”, to teach us Catholics what the Bible really says. But we do need challenging folk as well, and I pray that this is not a symptom that WORD is becoming another easy-listening station, so to speak.

    Posted 15 Apr 2005 at 4:07 am
  5. John wrote:

    Phew! This is a ‘Hot’ one mate! Thanks for the link, deeply appreciated!
    GBYAY

    Posted 16 Apr 2005 at 2:39 am
  6. Steve Nicoloso wrote:

    So was he fired because:

    a) he called The Purpose-Driven [Insert Purpose-Deprived Thing] the moral, therapeutic, deistic schlock that it is?

    b) because he was an ill-informed anti-Catholic bigot?

    If (a) that really is too bad, and confirms my thesis that “safe” Christian Radio is anything but… If (b) then… well… that still seems like no reason to fire him. Seems we still all benefit from folks stirring up the stew a bit…

    We have a “Christian” Radio station here in N. Jersey that goes on-and-on now about how “safe for your whole family” they are. But I really have to wonder just how “safe” their milk-toast programming and profoundly insipid music really is… I have to wonder how many people will try to enter by the wide gate and broad way exactly because it seemed “safe.” “Safe” is exactly what mainstream CCM and X-ian broadcast radio is trying to be… and I can’t help but wonder just how dangerous being “safe” really is… Give me bare boobs @ the Superbowl anyday over this…

    Cheers!

    Posted 15 Apr 2005 at 2:58 pm
  7. John wrote:

    We live in a predominantly Christian country. Christians sue Christians every day, and it does no remarkable harm.

    Also, I don’t know that non-Christian radio stations pose a particular threat to children. We spend an awful lot of time and energy protecting children from some media threat which has never really been demonstrated to exist.

    Posted 15 Apr 2005 at 4:31 pm
  8. Funky Dung wrote:

    test

    Posted 07 Feb 2006 at 4:50 pm

Trackbacks & Pingbacks 4

  1. From Ales Rarus - A Rare Bird, A Strange Duck, One Funky Blog » Jerry Bowyer and the Catholic Church on 14 Feb 2006 at 4:03 pm

    […] Jerry Bowyer and the Catholic Church By Funky Dung Jerry Bowyer’s attitude toward the Catholic Church is definitely a lot better than his predecessor’s. Here are some podcasts from his show. “Jerry interviews Ronald Rychlak, author of ‘Righteous Gentiles: How Pius XII And the Catholic Church Saved Half a Million Jews from the Nazis’, about the tremendous sacrifice European Catholics made to resist Hitler and save Jews, and dispels the myths that Hitler was Christian and that Christians turned a blind eye to the Holocaust. “ “Jerry interviews George Weigel, author of ‘God’s Choice : Pope Benedict XVI and the Future of the Catholic Church,’ about Benedict and his path from priest to pontiff.” “Jerry interviews Father Richard John Neuhaus, editor-in-chief of First Things, about the long-standing relationship between the Catholic Church and the Democratic Party, and where they will go from here.” “Jerry interviews Raymond Arroyo, the host of ‘The World Over Live’ on the Enternal Word Television Network, about Christian journalism.” […]

  2. From Ales Rarus - A Rare Bird, A Strange Duck, One Funky Blog » I Want Manna, Not Mammon on 22 May 2006 at 3:03 pm

    […] I’ve been listening to the Jerry Bowyer Program on WORD-FM fairly often these days. Jerry replaced Marty Minto, who was fired under contentious circumstances. On the whole, I like the show. I like tone and style and I think Jerry handles callers well. There’s a good balance between charity and patience on the one hand and avoiding time-wasting arguments with nuts on the other. When he talks about Christian topics, I enjoy listening to him and calling the show. Something worries me, though. […]

  3. From Apology Forthcoming @ Ales Rarus on 04 Nov 2006 at 1:34 pm

    […] April 21st, 2005 by Funky Dung Once again, my overactive mouth (or in this case, keyboard) has gotten me in trouble. A rather unpleasant affair occurred at Evangelical Underground. When time permits, I will be publishing an apology to all involved. I will also be apologizing for snide comments I made in my Marty Minto post. My sincere hope is that valuable lessons have been learned by the participants and that those lessons can be passed on to our readers. Funky Dung […]

  4. From After the Fire @ Ales Rarus on 04 Nov 2006 at 2:10 pm

    […] Ever wonder what Marty Minto's been up to? […]

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *